QuickTopic logo Create New TopicNew Topic My TopicsMy Topics News
Zarthani.net banner

H. Beam Piper Mailing List and Discussion Forum

NOTICE: This is an archive of the original page; many original features may not function.
Skip to Messages
Welcome to the Zarthani.net H. Beam Piper mailing list and discussion forum. Initiated in October 2008 (after the demise of the original PIPER-L mailing list), this tool for shared communication among Piper fans provides an e-mail list and a discussion forum with on-line archives.
 
Membership in this moderated list/forum is by invitation only. (If you'd like an invitation please request one by sending a message to the Moderator.) In order for your messages to be approved for posting to the list you must be both registered with the QuickTopic site (click the "Sign In" link at the top-right of the page) and subscribed to receive messages from the list by e-mail (click the "Get email" button below).
 
Moderation will focus on keeping the discussion related to H. Beam Piper in a broadly interpreted sense. Off-topic posts or ad hominem comments will not be approved for posting and repeat offenders may be banned from posting to the list.
 
There is an annual subscription fee required to keep this list/forum free of advertisements and to provide expanded functionality such as the capability to post images. You can support the continued ad-free availability of this shared resource by making a contribution using the PayPal link at the top of the page. (You don't need a PayPal account to make a donation, just a credit card.) Thank you for whatever level of support you can afford.
^     All messages    << 1788-1803  1777-1787 of 2246  1761-1776 >>
1787
Jon CrockerPerson was signed in when posted
10-21-2017
03:30 UT
He did have a lot of forward-thinking items in his work - I first started reading him when I was 10? 12? I was genuinely shocked when I first found out how old the stories were.
1786
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-18-2017
04:38 UT
~
". . . big, chocolate-brown Brigadier-General Themistocles M'zangwe. . . ."

That's Carlos von Schlichten describing his deputy, the "Greco-African" officer who has his old job as commander of Konkrook military district on Uller.

M'zangwe is a South African surname. There also seems to have been a Greek immigrant community in South Africa at the time Beam was writing, composed primarily of folks who left Greece after World War II and the Greek Civil War which followed. So, presumably M'zangwe is a South African.

But here's the problem. At the time Beam was writing, the Afrikaner-led Nationalist government in South Africa had already implemented extensive elements of _apartheid_. No one named "M'zangwe" was serving as a general officer in the South African military when Beam was writing ~Uller Uprising~.

We know that the Afrikaners remained a potent influence in the (second) Terran Federation. Afrikaans is one of the component languages of Lingua Terra, after all.

Beam gives us no details in his Terro-human Future History yarns but clearly he imagined some sort of course-reversal in South Africa, a course in which a "Greco-African" could rise to general officer rank in the Uller Company army (and presumably to at least field officer rank in the Terran Federation Army before that) while speaking the "English-Spanish-Afrikaans-Portuguese mixture" that was Lingua Terra.

Just another way in which the ideas Beam portrayed in his yarns were years ahead of his time.

Tchau,

David
--
"That's probably why the Southern Hemisphere managed to stay out of the Third and Fourth World Wars." - Carlos von Schlichten (H. Beam Piper), ~Uller Uprising~
~
1785
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-04-2017
04:10 UT
~
Dale Ridder wrote:

> For that matter, being an historian, you would
> be surprised on how much of what you read is
> slanted in one direction or another, and how
> the approach to any given event changes over
> time.

The interesting thing is, I think we can see evidence of Beam doing this purposely in the Terra-human Future History. Consider, for example, how pitiless Trask and the Sword-Worlders--putting aside the Space Vikings themselves--are toward the hapless people in the Old Federation. These attitudes place them well outside what passed for "polite society" at the time Beam was writing. But these are folks, Beam is showing us, who are the descendants not only of those who lived through the Atomic Wars--which destroyed civilization on half of Terra--but also of those who managed to escape the collapse of interstellar civilization itself and the devastation of several entire worlds. What seems, at first, to be an "error"--or at least an odd, unsettling characterization--turns out to be some rather subtle story-telling.

> As for the problem of Niflheim's location, I
> suspect that he simply moved the star to make
> the story work better, given the speed at which
> he was using for his hyperdrive in Uller Uprising.

I think there may have been several unusual things going on in this early "shared world" yarn. For example, while he sticks with Nu Puppis as Nifflheim's system, Beam moves his Uller from Clark's Beta Hydri, in the southern constellation Hydrus, to Beta Hydrae, in the northern constellation Hydra. That seems an odd mistake for him _and_ his editor to make--especially if it was Fletcher Pratt doing the editing for ~The Petrified Planet~. (Pratt's "The Long View" doesn't seem to mention the system its Uller is in, but its original publication in ~Startling Stories~ also included Clark's essay with the Beta Hydri reference.) On the other hand, there is no obvious dramatic reason why Beam might have made this shift.

I think you're right that Beam's primary focus was writing yarns that sold and therefore that his universe-building took a backseat to the dramatic needs he believed best-suited his interests in selling his work. On the other hand, I don't think we should be too quick to dismiss what seem to be errors or contradictions. I'm sure Beam made errors, yes, and at other times deliberately contradicted himself in a later work because that fit his dramatic needs at the time. But it's also clear that he often wrote with great care and that sometimes what seem to be inconsistencies--like the seemingly "six months to everywhere" phenomenon--can actually be understood in ways that reveal socio-political aspects of the universe he was constructing.

Znidd suddabit!

David
--
"It is not . . . the business of an author of fiction to improve or inspire or educate his reader, or to save the world from fascism, communism, racism, capitalism, socialism, or anything else. [The author's] main objective is to purvey entertainment of the sort his reader wants. If he has done this, by writing interestingly about interesting people, human or otherwise, doing interesting things, he has discharged his duty and earned his check." - H. Beam Piper, "Double: Bill Symposium" interview
~
1784
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-04-2017
03:04 UT
~
Jon Crocker wrote:

> Obviously Piper's ideas changed and grew, so some
> things from early on were left by the wayside.

Yep. I think Dale's right too that the source of this "growth" may often have been simply his desire to make a sale.

> It's too bad he never got a chance to compile a final,
> definitive version.

I agree it's a shame he didn't produce more work but I suspect that had his life not been cut short he still would never have lived long enough to do this (and that had he done so and tried, we'd be arguing now about many of the choices he made to "reconcile" bits here and there).

Cheers,

David
--
"Why Walt Disney bought the movie rights to ['Rebel Raider'], I've never figured out. Will Colonel Mosby be played by Mickey Mouse, and General Phil Sheridan by Donald Duck? It's baffling. However, I was glad to get the check." -- H. Beam Piper, The Pennsy interview, 1953
~
1783
Jon CrockerPerson was signed in when posted
10-04-2017
02:55 UT
"A little under six months to Terra from Uller, and then a couple of paragraphs later, six months from Niflheim to Uller."

Those aren't mutually exclusive.
1782
Dale RidderPerson was signed in when posted
10-04-2017
01:50 UT
I am not sure if Piper really view his Terran Future History in that light of having a final, definitive version, as he kept changing things. If you go through his books, his hyperdrive travel times are all over the map, sometimes in the same book. Then in Little Fuzzy making mention of time dilation effects just adds to the confusion. He was writing stories to sell, not history books. For that matter, being an historian, you would be surprised on how much of what you read is slanted in one direction or another, and how the approach to any given event changes over time. How many history books covering World War 2 are out there that start with either Pearl Harbor or the invasion of Poland, with no coverage of any of the wars going on in other places?

As for the problem of Niflheim's location, I suspect that he simply moved the star to make the story work better, given the speed at which he was using for his hyperdrive in Uller Uprising. Remember that this appears in Uller Uprising. "Oh, Orgzild wouldn't be crazy enough to try anything like that," Commander Dirk Prinsloo, of the Aldebaran, declared. "He'd get away with it for just twelve months—the time it would take to get the news to Terra and for a Federation Space Navy task-force to get here. And then, there'd be little bits of radioactive geek floating around this system as far out as the orbit of Beta Hydrae VII."

A little under six months to Terra from Uller, and then a couple of paragraphs later, six months from Niflheim to Uller. As I said, he was writing a story and wanted to have the communications lag in there, similar to what existed between India and Great Britain during the Indian Mutiny, which clearly is what Uller Uprising is based on.
1781
Jon CrockerPerson was signed in when posted
10-04-2017
00:00 UT
Obviously Piper's ideas changed and grew, so some things from early on were left by the wayside. It's too bad he never got a chance to compile a final, definitive version.
1780
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-02-2017
03:30 UT
~
Gregg Levine wrote:

> Little Fuzzy, and in there a question looms
> regarding the lowest known sapient race,
> and someone mentioned the Yggdrasill one.

It's interesting that while the Khooghras are mentioned in the Fuzzy novels they don't seem to be mentioned, by name, in any other Terro-human Future History yarns. Even the epithet "son of a Khooghra" only seems to appear in the Fuzzy novels.

The Yggdrasil native sophonts are also mentioned in ~Uller Uprising~ (though not in the abridged "Ullr Uprising") and in "When in the Course--" but we don't get details in either of those yarns which tell us much about the relative intelligence of the Khooghras as compared to other sapient races.

What we do get in the Fuzzy novels about the Khoogras is wide-ranging enough to suggests that their "just barely sapient" character is more than simply the subjective opinion of one or two folks like Holloway or Van Riebeek. It seems reasonable to conclude the Khooghras of Yggdrasil are indeed the least intelligent of known sapient races, at least at the time of the Fuzzy yarns.

Yeek.

David
--
"I saw a man shot once on Mimir, for calling another man a son of a Khooghra. The man who shot him had been on Yggdrasil and knew what he was being called." - Jack Holloway (H. Beam Piper), ~Little Fuzzy~
~
1779
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-01-2017
19:28 UT
~
Gregg Levine wrote:

> It would be interesting to find out if anyone
> did map out the entire region of space that
> the Terran Federation inhabits.

Nils Jeppe is your guy:

http://www.enderra.com/2011/11/17/mapping-h-beam-piper-part-1/

He has some thoughts about Niflheim too:

http://www.enderra.com/2011/11/24/mapping-...er-part-3-niflheim/

Enjoy,

David
--
". . . in one of the big hollow buildings that had stood since Khepera had been a Member Republic of the Terran Federation." - Lucas Trask (H. Beam Piper), ~Space Viking~
~
1778
Gregg LevinePerson was signed in when posted
10-01-2017
17:53 UT
I agree too! (To quote an oft used phrase.)
Everytime I read my copy of Uller Uprising, or the e-book version, depending on which one I've got available, that phrase pops up and naturally I end up musing on it. Heck! my first book in the TF series of stories, was in fact Little Fuzzy, and in there a question looms regarding the lowest known sapient race, and someone mentioned the Yggdrasill one. It would be interesting to find out if anyone did map out the entire region of space that the Terran Federation inhabits.
"YEEK!"
1777
David "PiperFan" JohnsonPerson was signed in when posted
10-01-2017
16:17 UT
~
Are Yggdrasil and Loki in the same system?

"Once, on a three-months' reaction-drive voyage from Yggdrasill to Loki, he had taught a couple of professors of extraterrestrial zoology to play _kriegspiel_. . . ."

That's Carlos von Schlichten musing about his time on Yggdrasil in ~Uller Uprising~ as Paula Quinton is moving forces around on her makeshift situation-map. (In this scene Quinton is being a bit ruthless; it's cut from the shorter "Ullr Uprising.") A "reaction-drive" (or "reaction drive") seems to be mentioned only one other time in the Terro-human Future History. In "Graveyard of Dreams" it seems to be some sort of normal-space drive. (In the slightly different, corresponding scene in ~Junkyard Planet~, Beam actually uses the term "normal-space drive" rather than "reaction drive.")

If Von Schlichten traveled from Yggdrasil to Loki in three months on a normal-space drive ship that would suggest the two planets are in the same system. Yggdrasil and Loki, which are mentioned in several Terro-human Future History yarns as planets with their own, respective native sophont races, don't ever seem to be explicitly described as being in the same system. In particular, when the ~Stellex~ explorers on Freya establish a trading relationship with Yggdrasil there is no mention of Loki being in the same system (even though the Loki Company is mentioned in the yarn). I suppose it's possible that Loki was in the same system but wasn't mentioned because ~Stellex~ is sent to Yggdrasil specifically to trade for nitrates. Perhaps Loki wasn't mentioned simply because it wasn't considered.

Still, it seems unlikely that there would be two planets with native sophont races in the same system. A Loki-Yggdrasil system would have to have a rather substantial habitable zone!

It's possible, of course, that the "reaction-drive" Von Schlichten described in ~Uller Uprising~ was simply a "slower-than-hyperdrive-but-still-faster-than-light drive." This was, after all, Beam's first Terro-human Future History yarn and it should not surprise us that he had not yet worked out all of the technology yet.

Znidd suddabit!

David
--
"I believe the first one, also a General von Schlichten, was what was then known as a war-criminal." - Carlos von Schlichten (H. Beam Piper), ~Uller Uprising~
~
^     All messages    << 1788-1803  1777-1787 of 2246  1761-1776 >>

Print | RSS Views: 35310 (Unique: 9358 ) / Subscribers: 27 | What's this?