QuickTopic logo Create New TopicNew Topic My TopicsMy Topics News
Zarthani.net banner

H. Beam Piper Mailing List and Discussion Forum

NOTICE: QuickTopic is shutting down soon. Learn more.
Skip to Messages
Welcome to the Zarthani.net H. Beam Piper mailing list and discussion forum. Initiated in October 2008 (after the demise of the original PIPER-L mailing list), this tool for shared communication among Piper fans provides an e-mail list and a discussion forum with on-line archives.
 
Membership in this moderated list/forum is by invitation only. (If you'd like an invitation please request one by sending a message to the Moderator.) In order for your messages to be approved for posting to the list you must be both registered with the QuickTopic site (click the "Sign In" link at the top-right of the page) and subscribed to receive messages from the list by e-mail (click the "Get email" button below).
 
Moderation will focus on keeping the discussion related to H. Beam Piper in a broadly interpreted sense. Off-topic posts or ad hominem comments will not be approved for posting and repeat offenders may be banned from posting to the list.
 
There is an annual subscription fee required to keep this list/forum free of advertisements and to provide expanded functionality such as the capability to post images. You can support the continued ad-free availability of this shared resource by making a contribution using the PayPal link at the top of the page. (You don't need a PayPal account to make a donation, just a credit card.) Thank you for whatever level of support you can afford.
^     All messages    << 297-312  257-296 of 2246  241-256 >>
296
David Johnson
08-29-2009
07:07 UT
~
Beyond Fifth Level: Therapod Cradle

Jon Crocker wrote:

> Or would early paratimers have decided to place a ban on sectors
> inhabited by descendants of velociraptors? :)

Back in 1994-95 I was involved in the development of an alternate history role-playing game called Infinite Earths. The effort never came to fruition but a very sketchy and clunky version of some of the development material is available here:

http://www.zarthani.net/InfiniteEarths/index.html

As you can see one of the alternate settings was called "Theropod Cradle," the idea being a world in which _two_ sentient species evolved on Earth: humans and another, sentient reptilian race (with their own "cradles of civilization"). Most of the development of this setting never got much beyond the brainstorming phase--I have bits and pieces of various unorganized e-mail discussions. It occurs to me though that with our new ideas about areas of Paratime which might exist "beyond" what Beam's Paratimers know as the Fifth Level there might be a place somewhere in Paratime for this sort of setting.
A few years back I and another Piper fan (still lurking here on the list, I believe) had an off-line discussion about Therapod Cradle but at the time didn't believe it was "on topic" for Piper because such a setting didn't fit in the five known Levels of Paratime. We'd even mentioned then that what would be needed was some sort of "Sixth Level" (though we had no idea how to conceive of such a thing back then). Well, perhaps the Therapod Cradle Basic Sector-Group exists in some eddy of Paratime a few millions "para-years" away from the "para-vortex" centered on the Home Timeline of Verkan Vall. . . .
Down Lizardmen!

David
--
"You know, it's never a mistake to take a second look at anything that everybody believes." - Rodney Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
295
David Johnson
08-28-2009
03:52 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

>> (Alternatively, you must still then explain the "para-peeping" if you
>> choose to go with the alternative explanation for the identify
>> verification.)
>
> I *did* explain how the para-peeping could have happened.
> Verkan was looking /en passant/ at one of the doppelgangers at
> the fake duplicate ParaCop HQ. I also explained why the
> reaction when he told the young lady in question was laughter
> instead of shock.

Ah, I didn't understand that the first time 'round. I see what you mean now.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"Captain, you almost make me believe in luck." - Mr. Spock,
_Star_Trek_, "A Taste of Armageddon"
~
294
Lensman
08-28-2009
03:47 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

>> But we can speculate. Note that Verkan Vall was checked in that
>> story to see if he was "our" Verkan Vall. Why? Obvious
>> implication: Someone had been using "doubles" of Paratime Police,
>> substituting them for the real person, as part of some nefarious
>> scheme.
>
> That's a clever trope to explain the identity verification, but my
> point was that Beam may have had some other idea in mind to explain
> why there was only a single Home Timeline in later Paratime yarns

Sure. But he left no explanation, so if we want one we've got to make it up ourselves. Piper chose to just ignore it in later stories.
> (Alternatively, you must still then explain the "para-peeping" if you
> choose to go with the alternative explanation for the identify
> verification.)

I *did* explain how the para-peeping could have happened. Verkan was looking /en passant/ at one of the doppelgangers at the fake duplicate ParaCop HQ. I also explained why the reaction when he told the young lady in question was laughter instead of shock.

> Neat idea but I'm not sure it fits quite right with the other
> information in the Paratime canon.

Yah, well I posted it here to see if y'all could shoot holes in it. Better to find the flaws now before anyone tries to write a story using the ideas.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
293
David Johnson
08-28-2009
03:46 UT
~
Jon Crocker wrote:

> OK, I admit this is a little 'out there', but just how far does
> "Paratime" go?
>
> Could it include belts where various natural disasters didn't
> happen, or were worse? Krakatoa didn't happen, or the 1908
> Tunguska event happened over a city, for example? If a whole
> sector arose from a migration east instead of west, what would
> happen if Moscow, or London, or Berlin were wiped out by a big
> meteor?

I think the "weather" issue suggests that Beam intended for the changes from one timeline to another to be the sole result of some sort of sapient action, so in general this would not be the case.
Of course, "The Answer" makes it clear that Beam had some pretty interesting ideas about the possibilities for agency in the
universe. Perhaps whatever it was that hit Tunguska was not the result of a natually-occurring phenomenon after all. . . .

Down Styphon!

David
--
"Never let your sense of morals prevent you from doing what is
right." - Salvor Hardin
~
292
David Johnson
08-28-2009
03:39 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> The line about the weather being
> the same from one end of Paratime to the other-- regardless of
> how unlikely that may be-- is a strong indication to me that
> natural forces do not vary from timeline to timeline.

I agree with Lensman. ;)

>> Or would early paratimers have decided to place a ban on sectors
>> inhabited by descendants of velociraptors? :)
>
[snip]
> Maybe if they kept going, they'd find sectors where
> intelligent descendants of Velociraptor were building cities!

I believe this is a reasonable supposition. The Paratimers are parasites who never left the Sol system prior to discovering
paratemporal transposition. Thus, they are content merely to exploit the timelines nearest to a Terra populated by the descendants of Martian immigrants who had depleted the resources of their own world millennia ago. They've come nowhere near depleting the resources of this "super-cluster" of timelines and so it's never occurred to them to travel any farther cross-time. . . .

Perhaps it makes more sense to think of the "structure" of Paratime in terms of a series of ever-larger concentric circles or rings--with Home Timeline at the "center"--rather than in terms of "Levels." Thus, perhaps somewhere "beyond" the outermost, "Fifth Level" of uninhabited Earth timelines are even more distant timelines where Martians never evolved on Mars and who knows what--sentient, quasi- velociraptors even--evolved on Earth instead.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"You know, it's never a mistake to take a second look at anything that everybody believes." - Rodney Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
291
David Johnson
08-28-2009
03:27 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> At the least, small local weather patterns will be affected by
> such things as you mention-- draining swamps and the like.
>
> Personally I'd rather find some way to explain away any apparent
> impossibilities or contradictions in the canon, but I admit in
> this case I can't think of anything to make it work. So
> altho I don't like the idea of just ignoring something the
> canon states is true, in this case it may be best.

I'm with you both on the inclination to "make the canon work" if at all possible as a general rule and on the unfortunate conclusion in this instance that the cross-time weather conundrum is a tough nut to crack.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"A girl can punch any kind of a button a man can, and a lot of them knew what buttons to punch, and why." - Conn Maxwell (H. Beam Piper), _The_Cosmic_Computer_
~
290
David Johnson
08-28-2009
03:23 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> But we can speculate. Note that Verkan Vall was checked in that
> story to see if he was "our" Verkan Vall. Why? Obvious
> implication: Someone had been using "doubles" of Paratime
> Police, substituting them for the real person, as part of some
> nefarious scheme.

That's a clever trope to explain the identity verification, but my point was that Beam may have had some other idea in mind to explain why there was only a single Home Timeline in later Paratime yarns, not just to explain why Verkan was checked in "Police Operation" to make sure he was the "correct" Verkan. I mean, it wasn't simply that his identify was verified--he actually "para-peeped" at that redhead on another timeline and then _met_ her on "his" timeline! If we have to throw this out as an unfortunate "learning experience" in Beam's first Paratime yarn, why not throw out the checking of his identity as well?

(Alternatively, you must still then explain the "para-peeping" if you choose to go with the alternative explanation for the identify
verification.)

> It must have been a shock to discover
> that you've got an exact double living in a building just like
> yours, who thinks they *are* you. How do you react? Either
> laugh or cry. For the sake of their mental health, the Paratime
> Police were encouraged by counselors and supervisors to laugh.

Hmmm. We already begin to suspect in "Time Crime" that the Bureau of Psychological Hygiene--those "counselors and supervisors"--has been infiltrated by the mysterious and nefarious Organization behind the Wizard Traders. . . .

Neat idea but I'm not sure it fits quite right with the other
information in the Paratime canon.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"The Terro-Human Future History . . . has a historian's attention to sociological and political detail that is unsurpassed." - John F. Carr, Introduction to _Empire_
~
289
Gilmoure
08-27-2009
14:58 UT
That would explain the Paratime Police car and guys in uniform that took out Salvor Trod (sp?) when he was being brought in.
G

On Wed, Aug 26, 2009 at 11:34 PM, QT - Lensman <
qtopic-42-tnfVKeAH3s4T@quicktopic.com> wrote:

>
< replied-to message removed by QT >
288
Lensman
08-27-2009
07:34 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

 > Lensman sez:
>> Now it seems doubly odd that the one single
>> first-level timeline would be the one timeline out of a
>> near-infinite number which developed cross-time travel. The
>> obvious conclusion is that it's no coincidence at all-- that
>> there's something about the probability of developing
>> cross-time travel that made it likely on the one First Level
>> timeline, but no where else.
>
> Unless, of course, there is a "Meta-Paratime" civilization
> secretly manipulating the Paratime civilization in a manner
> akin to the way in which the Paratimers secretly manipulate
> the other civilizations of Paratime.

Well it seems I made a fundamental error. Recent posts have talked about different sectors in First Level. So it's just the Home Timeline which has not been duplicated... and *not* that there's only one timeline in the First Level.

But you have an interesting hypothesis there, which obviously could lead to an unlimited number of steps in a hierarchy...

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
287
Lensman
08-27-2009
07:17 UT
QT - Gilmoure wrote:

> And since it appears that new timelines arise from the agency of
> the extra physical componant, it almost seems that a certain
> type of intellegence is required.

Can you point to any story which actually says a new timeline was created?
> Another thing I wonder is what is the scale of paratime? Is it
> localized to human observed reality? Do multiple timelines merge
> back in to one unseen universe out there?

I too have wondered about this. Is what the Paratimers think of as the entirety of Paratime actually all of it? Or is it just what their cross-time-travel machines are capable of reaching? Might it be that what they call Paratime is just one branch of a tree? Might other branches have intelligent dinosaurs, or something even more fantastic? Maybe some branches are inhabited by races from a planet more distant than Mars? Might one branch even be ruled by a species which evolved on a planet other Mars or Earth?

And if that EPC mumbo-jumbo really does have some physical reality, and isn't just some sort of Paratimer religion, then is the way Paratimers perceive the reality of different timelines the objective reality? Or could it be that either:

1. There is only one reality and only one timeline; it's just subjective human perception that differs from place to place and culture to culture. (But then, how/why do the cross-time conveyors work?)

2. There are no distinct timelines, but rather an infinity of shadings from one to another. Humans can only perceive reality at certain probability levels or only at certain Paratime resonance frequencies. (Might there be other species which can also only perceive certain Paratime resonance frequencies; frequencies which are out of sync with the Human ones? Might there be other Paratime cultures interspersed with the Human Paratime culture? And what would happen if one somehow discovered another?)

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
286
Lensman
08-27-2009
07:01 UT
QT - Jon Crocker wrote:

> Could it include belts where various natural disasters didn't
> happen, or were worse? Krakatoa didn't happen, or the 1908
> Tunguska event happened over a city, for example? If a whole
> sector arose from a migration east instead of west, what would
> happen if Moscow, or London, or Berlin were wiped out by a big
> meteor?

Yes indeed, this is a question I've always wanted to see addressed in a Paratime story. Do natural events also vary from timeline to timeline? The line about the weather being the same from one end of Paratime to the other-- regardless of how unlikely that may be-- is a strong indication to me that natural forces do not vary from timeline to timeline. Apparently Chaos Theory need not apply, or if it does it's only on a very fine scale; on the gross scale, natural events happen identically on all the timelines. Perhaps even the weather *tends* to be the same on all timelines, with local variations for local
conditions, but with local variations damped out over distance and time. Since we don't know just what mechanism keeps adjacent timelines from drifting ever farther apart as time passes, it may be that this same mechanism keeps weather the same (except for the aforementioned local variations) across all Paratime.

 > For an even wilder question - is there a paratime sector where > the dinosaur-killer asteroid didn't smack into the earth 65
 > million years back?
 >
 > Or would early paratimers have decided to place a ban on sectors > inhabited by descendants of velociraptors? :)

How much of Paratime has been surveyed? We know most timelines haven't been visited. Has there been any attempt to survey paratime from one end to the other? Or did surveying peter out when they stopped
discovering inhabited timelines? If the latter, then who knows? Maybe if they kept going, they'd find sectors where intelligent descendants of Velociraptor were building cities!

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
285
Lensman
08-27-2009
06:47 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

> David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:
>
>> Also, one story said the weather was the same on *all* timelines.
>> So altho human actions and history varies on different timelines,
>> not everything does.
>
> This was simply an error, in my view. It comes from an era when
> the influence of human activity upon climate was not widely
> recognized. And even Beam "got smarter" on this point. By
> the Fuzzy novels he was noting that efforts to drain a massive
> swamp on Zarathustra was having an effect on the climate.

There's a theory that human activity, perhaps something as simple as sheep grazing killing off grass-- but perhaps also slash-and-burn agriculture-- has caused or at least accelerated the desertification of North Africa. If this is true, then uninhabited timelines will have less desert in North Africa, which will have significant effect on global weather patterns. At the least, small local weather patterns will be affected by such things as you mention-- draining swamps and the like.

Personally I'd rather find some way to explain away any apparent impossibilities or contradictions in the canon, but I admit in this case I can't think of anything to make it work. So altho I don't like the idea of just ignoring something the canon states is true, in this case it may be best.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
284
David Johnson
08-27-2009
06:39 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> Now it seems doubly odd that the one single
> first-level timeline would be the one timeline out of a
> near-infinite number which developed cross-time travel. The
> obvious conclusion is that it's no coincidence at all-- that
> there's something about the probability of developing
> cross-time travel that made it likely on the one First Level
> timeline, but no where else.

Unless, of course, there is a "Meta-Paratime" civilization secretly manipulating the Paratime civilization in a manner akin to the way in which the Paratimers secretly manipulate the other civilizations of Paratime.

;)

Down Styphon!

David
--
"You know, it's never a mistake to take a second look at anything that everybody believes." - Rodney Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
283
David Johnson
08-27-2009
06:35 UT
~
Glenn "Gilmoure" Amspaugh wrote:

> And since it appears that new timelines arise from the agency of
> the extra physical componant, it almost seems that a certain
> type of intellegence is required.

Agreed.

> Do dogs or dolphins or fuzzies have an EPC? If so, can they move
> through time and carry future memories with them?

Dolphins perhaps. Not Fuzzies though because they don't exist in Paratime. ;)

Down Styphon!

David
--
"I hope I've made the point, without over-making it, that the
proletariat aren't good and virtuous, only stupid, weak and
incompetent." - H. Beam Piper (on "A Slave is a Slave")
~
282
Lensman
08-27-2009
06:34 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

> Given that it's clear Beam was making a conscious choice to
> portray the Home Timeline Paratimers differently after "Police
>
> Operation" (apparently having realized that the device of
> multiple Verkan Vall's simply wasn't going to work in a series
> of Paratime yarns) I like to believe he had a solution in mind
> here, rather than was merely "sweeping under the rug" an
> inconvenient portayal in his first Paratime yarn.
>
> Of course, what that "solution" might have been, we may never
> know.

But we can speculate. Note that Verkan Vall was checked in that story to see if he was "our" Verkan Vall. Why? Obvious implication: Someone had been using "doubles" of Paratime Police, substituting them for the real person, as part of some nefarious scheme. Most likely this involved cloning individuals and growing them in an accelerated fashion. Remember that the Paratime culture has the ability to... what's it called? Narco-hypnotize? Anyway, to impose information and personality on a brain without having to take the time for the normal learning. So all the Evil Mastermind (or Cabal) has to do is grow these bodies, then program them to think and act like the real person. Except, of course, they'll be instructed to carry out some carefully laid plans...

Naturally the EM or Cabal imports some proles to build a duplicate of the Paratime Police headquarters on a First Level timeline not too far from the Paratime timelin, so the doppelgangers can become familiar with the layout of the building and the everyday routine of people working in the Paratime Police HQ. How did the EM/C hide the duplicate HQ from observation by traveling Paratimers? That would be part of the story, of course.

By the time of the first Paratime story, the plot had been discovered, unusual security techniques involving blood testing had been temporarily established, and the existence of the doppleganger Paratime Police HQ had become a big joke to the real Paratime Police. It must have been a shock to discover that you've got an exact double living in a building just like yours, who thinks they *are* you. How do you react? Either laugh or cry. For the sake of their mental health, the Paratime Police were encouraged by counselors and supervisors to laugh.

Since this was never mentioned again, it seems likely the
dopplegangers-- after some delay while policy was argued at the highest levels and hammered out-- were gathered up and... well, just how ruthless are the Paratimers? The smart thing to do would be to kill the doubles, to prevent them from being used in another similar plot. But if the Paratimers couldn't bring themselves to kill doubles of
themselves, perhaps the doubles were shipped to some far-off backwater uninhabited timeline and quietly guarded to live out a normal lifespan. Which would leave room for a sequel...

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
281
David Johnson
08-27-2009
06:32 UT
~
Jack Russell wrote:

> The way Piper wrote it, the weather was the same from time-line
> to time-line, suggesting that all things being equal, the were
> the same, Now today we know that human activity can affect the
> weather. Piper himself seemed to realize this in Little Fuzzy
> as previously mentioned. As such, we have to assume that only
> the changes caused by humans (or Martian colonists if you
> prefer) would have an effect on the weather.

I think that's right. Without some sort of sapient agency each paratime timeline would be the same. Of course, over time it might be difficult to unravel what the particular impact of sapient agency is on a given timeline. But it seems clear that it was Beam's
interest in history which led him to the concept of multiple,
alternate timelines and it is sapient (human) agency which drives history.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"I remember, when I was just a kid, about a hundred and fifty years ago--a hundred and thirty-nine, to be exact--I picked up a fellow on the Fourth Level, just about where you're operating, and dragged him a couple of hundred parayears. I went back to find him and return him to his own time-line, but before I could locate him, he'd been
arrested by the local authorities as a suspicious character, and got himself shot trying to escape. I felt badly about that. . . ." - Tortha Karf, "Police Operation"
~
280
David Johnson
08-27-2009
06:28 UT
~
Jon Crocker wrote:

> I think the 'multiple Verkans' got dropped when Piper realized
> that there was exactly one Home Time Line, and many of the other
> First Level timelines were depopulated wastelands.
>
> Now if it were a cluster of timelines that had the Paratime
> Secret, I bet he would have run with it.

No, I think "para-peeping Verkan" was simply a clever idea which helped to make the story appealing to Beam's _Astounding_ readers when he had first conceived of the Paratime Police but one that he realized would become unmanageable once he started writing more Paratime Police yarns.

Down Styphon!

David
--
"You know, most of the wars they've been fighting, lately, on the Europo-American Sector have been, at least in part, motivated by rivalry for oil fields." - H. Beam Piper, "Temple Trouble," 1951
~
279
Lensman
08-27-2009
05:57 UT
QT - Jack Russell wrote:

> It seems to me that there should be multiple sectors of 1st
> level. At the very minimum, one where cross-time transposition
> became possible, and one where it never happened. I suspect
> the non-timeline sector would have used up all the resources
> and either left for the stars (they have had millinia to get
> the tech straight on that since coming to Earth) or devolved
> into barbarism. That's two more sub-sectors. Even if we
> ignore the possibility of splitting off realities, shouldn't
> those probable time-lines already exist?

Well, whether or not we think such timelines *ought* to exist, the canon is quite clear that only one timeline has developed cross-time travel. Now it seems doubly odd that the one single first-level timeline would be the one timeline out of a near-infinite number which developed cross-time travel. The obvious conclusion is that it's no coincidence at all-- that there's something about the probability of developing cross-time travel that made it likely on the one First Level timeline, but no where else.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
278
Jack Russell
08-27-2009
03:17 UT
5th level is uninhabited by Martian colonists, Only Neanderthals who never achieved civilization higher than stone-age tech live there...and 1st level retirees and the odd 1st level industries.

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
277
Gilmoure
08-27-2009
02:10 UT
And since it appears that new timelines arise from the agency of the extra physical componant, it almost seems that a certain type of intellegence is required.

Do dogs or dolphins or fuzzies have an EPC? If so, can they move through time and carry future memories with them?

Another thing I wonder is what is the scale of paratime? Is it
localized to human observed reality? Do multiple timelines merge back in to one unseen universe out there?

Gilmoure

On Aug 26, 2009, at 6:27 PM, QT - Jack Russell <qtopic-42-tnfVKeAH3s4T@quicktopic.com > wrote:

< replied-to message removed by QT >
276
Jack Russell
08-27-2009
01:27 UT
The way Piper wrote it, the weather was the same from time-line to time-line, suggesting that all things being equal, the were the same, Now today we know that human activity can affect the weather. Piper himself seemed to realize this in Little Fuzzy as previously mentioned. As such, we have to assume that only the changes caused by humans (or Martian colonists if you prefer) would have an effect on the weather. Fluorocarbons in the atmosphere brings on global warming and flooding and related atmospheric disturbances. This would not affect meteor activity or volcanic activity unless the civilization is advanced enough to bore significantly into the earth's crust.

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
275
Jon CrockerPerson was signed in when posted
08-27-2009
00:47 UT
OK, I admit this is a little 'out there', but just how far does "Paratime" go?

Could it include belts where various natural disasters didn't happen, or were worse? Krakatoa didn't happen, or the 1908 Tunguska event happened over a city, for example? If a whole sector arose from a migration east instead of west, what would happen if Moscow, or London, or Berlin were wiped out by a big meteor?

For an even wilder question - is there a paratime sector where the dinosaur-killer asteroid didn't smack into the earth 65 million years back?

Or would early paratimers have decided to place a ban on sectors inhabited by descendants of velociraptors? :)

Jon
274
Jon CrockerPerson was signed in when posted
08-26-2009
05:10 UT
I think the 'multiple Verkans' got dropped when Piper realized that there was exactly one Home Time Line, and many of the other First Level timelines were depopulated wastelands.

Now if it were a cluster of timelines that had the Paratime Secret, I bet he would have run with it.

Would the Kalvan timeline "need time to develop into a subsector?" He pretty much started changing things on day one, and ended up King before too long. Those university types were pretty pleased with the research opportunities.

Of course, it would be a 'subsector of one' since only one Calvan Morrison was swept to Hostigos.

Jon
273
David Johnson
08-26-2009
04:59 UT
~
Re: The Extraphysical Component (EPC)

Glenn "Gilmoure" Amspaugh wrote:

> that plays well with the example of VV to the Rocket pilot
> (going in to a bar, meets a girl, ends up shot dead and his
> extra-ego component (?) (at work; no access to Piper) goes back
> and over to next timeline and influences him to skip first bar
> and go elsewhere.

Actually, Verkan is not talking about an actual person doing this but the guy's "extraphysical component." It would seem he was thinking more here about what happened to Allan Hartley in "Time and Time Again" or perhaps the reincarnating people of Akor Neb in "Last Enemy."
> Look forward to hearing your retcon of first Paratime story. As
> long as it has multiple cute redheads taking showers. That's
> always a plus.

Hear, hear!

David
--
"Do you know which books to study, and which ones not to bother with? Or which ones to read first, so that what you read in the others will be comprehensible to you? That's what they'll give you [at
university] on Terra. The tools, which you don't have now, for
educating yourself." - Bish Ware (H. Beam Piper), _Four-Day_Planet_
272
David Johnson
08-26-2009
04:42 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> Also, one
> story said the weather was the same on *all* timelines. So
> altho human actions and history varies on different timelines,
> not everything does.

This was simply an error, in my view. It comes from an era when the influence of human activity upon climate was not widely recognized. And even Beam "got smarter" on this point. By the Fuzzy novels he was noting that efforts to drain a massive swamp on Zarathustra was having an effect on the climate.

> Aside from the first Paratime story, there's no hint of any
> "doppleganger" of any paratimer. And my impression is that most
> Piper fans would prefer to ignore that passage in the first
> story.

Count me in here. I'm willing to write it off as Beam still finding his "Paratime legs."

> In fact, I wish someone would write a story retconning
> an explanation for that which does *not* involve multiple First
> Level timelines. I've got some ideas about how to do that...


Oh, do tell!

David
--
"Good things in the long run are often tough while they're
happening." - Otto Harkaman (H. Beam Piper), _Space_Viking_
~
271
David Johnson
08-26-2009
04:36 UT
~
Re: Para-peeping Verkan Valls

Glenn "Gilmoure" Amspaugh wrote:

> Or is this being swept under the rug like the first Paratime
> story with Verkin Vall being checked to see which Verkin he was
> (he was the para-peeper)?

Given that it's clear Beam was making a conscious choice to portray the Home Timeline Paratimers differently after "Police
Operation" (apparently having realized that the device of multiple Verkan Vall's simply wasn't going to work in a series of Paratime yarns) I like to believe he had a solution in mind here, rather than was merely "sweeping under the rug" an inconvenient portayal in his first Paratime yarn.

Of course, what that "solution" might have been, we may never know.
Down Styphon!

David
--
"You know, it's never a mistake to take a second look at anything that everybody believes." - Rodney Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
270
David Johnson
08-25-2009
04:42 UT
~
Jack Russell wrote:

> It seems to me that there should be multiple sectors of 1st
> level.

There are at least two (in addition to the Home Timeline sector):
http://www.zarthani.net/timelines.htm

> At the very minimum, one where cross-time transposition
> became possible, and one where it never happened. I suspect
> the non-timeline sector would have used up all the resources
> and either left for the stars (they have had millinia to get
> the tech straight on that since coming to Earth) or devolved
> into barbarism.

That would be Dwarma Sector (from "Time Crime"):

"The people of the First Level Dwarma Sector, reduced by sheer
starvation to a tiny handful, had abandoned their cities and
renounced their technologies and created for themselves a farm-and- village culture without progress or change or curiosity or struggle or ambition, and a way of life in which every day was like every other day that had been or that would come."

And perhaps also Abzar Sector (also from "Time Crime"):

"The Abzar people had . . . wasted their resources to the last, fighting bitterly over the ultimate crumbs, with fission bombs, and with muskets, and with swords, and with spears and clubs, and finally they had died out, leaving a planet of almost uniform desert dotted with vast empty cities which even twelve thousand years had hardly begun to obliterate."



(I don't recall any mention of a First Level civilization which escaped to an interstellar destination. The Home Timeline folks were working on an interstellar drive when they discovered paratemporal transposition and subsequently abandon their interest in interstellar travel.)


Down Styphon!

David
--
"You know, most of the wars they've been fighting, lately, on the Europo-American Sector have been, at least in part, motivated by rivalry for oil fields." - H. Beam Piper, "Temple Trouble," 1951
~
269
Jack Russell
08-24-2009
23:03 UT
It seems to me that there should be multiple sectors of 1st level. At the very minimum, one where cross-time transposition became possible, and one where it never happened. I suspect the non-timeline sector would have used up all the resources and either left for the stars (they have had millinia to get the tech straight on that since coming to Earth) or devolved into barbarism. That's two more sub-sectors. Even if we ignore the possibility of splitting off realities, shouldn't those probable time-lines already exist?

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
268
Gilmoure
08-24-2009
23:01 UT
I like the idea of timelines influencing nearby timelines and that plays well with the example of VV to the Rocket pilot (going in to a bar, meets a girl, ends up shot dead and his extra-ego component (?) (at work; no access to Piper) goes back and over to next timeline and influences him to skip first bar and go elsewhere.
Look forward to hearing your retcon of first Paratime story. As long as it has multiple cute redheads taking showers. That's always a plus.

Gilmoure

On Mon, Aug 24, 2009 at 3:50 PM, QT - Lensman <
qtopic-42-tnfVKeAH3s4T@quicktopic.com> wrote:

>
< replied-to message removed by QT >
267
Lensman
08-24-2009
22:50 UT
QT - Jack Russell wrote:

> Calvin Morrison created a divergent timeline when he was
> uncerimoniously dumped into the Styphon subsector, yes? Now,
> as I understand it, sectors and subsectors are created by
> divergent probabilities. Well, it seems that there would also
> become numerous divergencies from the Kalvan line. Lets assume
> it takes a bit more than someone sleeping in or waking up early
> to create a divergence. Surely the various battles Kalvan has
> fought are significant enough to cause this. Many of his
> victories were of the good fortune type, or dependant on the
> actions of others. A betrayal in one timeline may not have
> occured in another creating a divergence. I would think that
> there would be several such divergences by now.

It would *appear* that the Kalvan timeline would, over time, develop into a subsector, but you won't find the slightest hint in the canon that there's more than one single timeline on which Kalvan exists.
> I would imagine that once a timeline has been identified, it
> would be "tagged" with an electronic beacon that would transmit
> a sort of homing signal...but then that signal would likely
> transmit from several timelines if it was there before the
> split. Then there is the matter of the study team. There
> would be duplicates of them as well. OY!
>
> Jack

IMHO this is pretty strong evidence that timelines do *not* split; that there is a fixed altho extremely large number of them. If timelines never split (or merge), if they've all been in existence since the beginning of time, then why are adjacent timelines more similar than distant ones? They must exert influence over each other; or rather, there is something exerting influence over timelines which causes a tendency for the same events to occur on adjacent ones. Something which damps out all but minor differences on adjacent timelines, but allows wider differences for more distant ones. Also, one story said the weather was the same on *all* timelines. So altho human actions and history varies on different timelines, not everything does.

Maybe this is like light; analyzed in one way, light is composed of waves. Analyzed another way, light is composed of discrete photons. Which is correct? Both, and neither. Perhaps it can be said of the timelines that they are both one and many.

Aside from the first Paratime story, there's no hint of any
"doppleganger" of any paratimer. And my impression is that most Piper fans would prefer to ignore that passage in the first story. In fact, I wish someone would write a story retconning an explanation for that which does *not* involve multiple First Level timelines. I've got some ideas about how to do that...

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
266
Jack Russell
08-24-2009
18:17 UT
I would imagine that once a timeline has been identified, it would be "tagged" with an electronic beacon that would transmit a sort of homing signal...but then that signal would likely transmit from several timelines if it was there before the split. Then there is the matter of the study team. There would be duplicates of them as well. OY!

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
265
Gilmoure
08-24-2009
18:05 UT
30+ years later, yeah, should be several centuries of Kalvin timelines. I wonder how they know which one is the study line? Or is this being swept under the rug like the first Paratime story with Verkin Vall being checked to see which Verkin he was (he was the para-peeper)?
Gilmoure

On Mon, Aug 24, 2009 at 9:09 AM, QT - Jack Russell <
qtopic-42-tnfVKeAH3s4T@quicktopic.com> wrote:

>
< replied-to message removed by QT >
264
Jack Russell
08-24-2009
16:09 UT
On this I have no information. But, it sparks another question.

Calvin Morrison created a divergent timeline when he was uncerimoniously dumped into the Styphon subsector, yes? Now, as I understand it, sectors and subsectors are created by divergent probabilities. Well, it seems that there would also become numerous divergencies from the Kalvan line. Lets assume it takes a bit more than someone sleeping in or waking up early to create a divergence. Surely the various battles Kalvan has fought are significant enough to cause this. Many of his victories were of the good fortune type, or dependant on the actions of others. A betrayal in one timeline may not have occured in another creating a divergence. I would think that there would be several such divergences by now.

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
263
David Johnson
08-24-2009
15:56 UT
~
Structure of Paratime: Basic Sector-Group?

Folks

I believe most of us are familiar with the general structure of Paratime: five Levels, each divided into Sectors which are further divided into Sub-sectors comprised of Belts of individual Timelines. While rereading "Temple Trouble" recently though, I came across something called the "Nilo-Mesopotamian Basic Sector-Group" which is a _collection_ of several Sectors, including Europo-American and Proto-Aryan where "Trouble" take place. I hadn't realized such an organizational grouping existed before. Looking a bit more closely at the other Paratime yarns, I see now that the Kholghoor Sector where "Time Crime" opens is part of a different Indus-Ganges-Irriwady Basic Sector-Group.

Has anyone else been aware of this component of Paratime structure before? If so, are you aware of any other "Basic Sector-Groups"? Do they exist on other Levels or are they unique to the "largest" Fourth Level?

Down Styphon!

David
--
"The Terro-Human Future History . . . has a historian's attention to sociological and political detail that is unsurpassed." - John F. Carr, Introduction to _Empire_
~
262
Fred Ramsey
08-14-2009
16:37 UT
David,

The book is mostly Del Rey's professional biography. I read it many years ago and don't remember there being anything of substance about Beam. Maybe someone who has read it more recently can comment further.

There are lots of copies available on Bookfinder.com, paperbacks under $10, hardcovers around $25.
261
David Johnson
08-09-2009
19:55 UT
~
Lester del Rey on H. Beam Piper?

The front page of the Gardland hardcover editions of _Space_Viking_ and _Lord_Kalvan_ states that they are part of a collection of 45 works selected by Lester del Rey, with a separate introductory
volume, _Science_Fiction,_1926-1976_, written especially for the collection. Has anyone ever read del Rey's book? What does it have to say about Piper and his work?

Thanks,

David
--
"Good things in the long run are often tough while they're
happening." - Otto Harkaman (H. Beam Piper), _Space_Viking_
~
260
Lensman
08-04-2009
22:15 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

> But if Von Schlichten merely means something like "civilized"
> here then why doesn't he just say that? Why talk about Uller
> one-day being "fit to admit to the Federation"? You may be
> right, of course, but I still find it hard to ignore the fact
> that at least two of the three planets mentioned by Von
> Schlichten here have native sapient species.

I'm not saying your suggestion is wrong, David. I was careful to characterize my alternate suggestion with "perhaps" in two places. You could be right. I just don't think it's conclusive, that's all.

Here's an alternate suggestion: Odin was colonized from earth, the colony revolted against the colonial governor, some time passed as an independent planet, then it had to be subjugated and brought back into the Federation. Wouldn't that fit the passage just as well?

Of course, you suggested something similar to that yourself, in the parent post. Since this would not require that we invent a native race for Odin which is not mentioned anywhere, ISTM that the principle of Occam's Razor says we should prefer this scenario.

Just my 2&#A2;.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
259
David Johnson
08-04-2009
13:54 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

>> In a couple of centuries, this planet will
>> be fit to admit to the Federation, like Odin and Freya."
>>
>> "Fit to admit to the Federation, like _Odin_"?
>
> Perhaps you're reading more into it than the author intended.
> Perhaps the character was just giving two examples of "highly
> civilized" planets. I don't think we need to assume a race of
> Odin natives from this passage.

I agree it's unclear and I've wondered if Von Schlichten isn't merely referring to some process by which _any_ extra-solar planet is
admitted to the Terran Federation. This is an early Federation-era yarn and there must have been a point early in the expansion of the Federation when a decision was made to start admitting colonized extra-solar planets to a Federation which had consisted up to that point only of planets in the Sol system like Terra and Venus and Mars (and perhaps Luna, Mercury, and Titan). So perhaps that political innovation was novel enough to still be forefront in Von Schlichten's mind.

But if Von Schlichten merely means something like "civilized" here then why doesn't he just say that? Why talk about Uller one-day being "fit to admit to the Federation"? You may be right, of course, but I still find it hard to ignore the fact that at least two of the three planets mentioned by Von Schlichten here have native sapient species.

Remember Ashmodai! Remember Belphegor!

David
--
"I hope I've made the point, without over-making it, that the
proletariat aren't good and virtuous, only stupid, weak and
incompetent." - H. Beam Piper (on "A Slave is a Slave")
~
258
Lensman
08-04-2009
06:51 UT
QT - David Johnson wrote:

> Natives on Odin!?!
>
> Folks,
>
> Here's a quote I ran across the other day in _Uller_Uprising_;
> it's General Von Schlichten speaking after the outbreak of
> rebellion among the native Ullerans:
>
> "There's going to have to be a Terran seizure of political power
> in every part of this planet that we occupy. . . . Then, we
> can start giving them government by law instead of by royal
> decree, and real courts of justice. . . . And, gradually,
> abolish serfdom. In a couple of centuries, this planet will
> be fit to admit to the Federation, like Odin and Freya."
>
> "Fit to admit to the Federation, like _Odin_"?

Perhaps you're reading more into it than the author intended. Perhaps the character was just giving two examples of "highly civilized" planets. I don't think we need to assume a race of Odin natives from this passage.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
257
David Johnson
08-03-2009
14:01 UT
~
Natives on Odin!?!

Folks,

Here's a quote I ran across the other day in _Uller_Uprising_; it's General Von Schlichten speaking after the outbreak of rebellion among the native Ullerans:

"There's going to have to be a Terran seizure of political power in every part of this planet that we occupy. . . . Then, we can start giving them government by law instead of by royal decree, and real courts of justice. . . . And, gradually, abolish serfdom. In a couple of centuries, this planet will be fit to admit to the
Federation, like Odin and Freya."

"Fit to admit to the Federation, like _Odin_"? Now, we know that Freya had a native "Freyo-human" race which, among other things, prevented the original Terran colonists from claiming rights to the entire planet. But what could have been the situation on Odin that would have led to it being _admitted_ to the Federation in some context which Von Schlicht finds relevant to the pacification of the native population on Uller? I had always assumed that Odin had simply been colonized by settlers from Terra (perhaps under the auspices of a chartered company).

I'm not sure of any suggestion elsewhere in the Terro-human Future History (TFH) yarns of a native race on Odin and _Uprising_ has many inconsistencies in it, being written several years before any of the rest of Beam's TFH yarns. Or, could it be that instead of a native race, the early Terran settlers on Odin somehow managed to enjoy an early period _independent_ of the Federation? If so, that would be something new too.

Anyone run across any references to Odin elsewhere which might shed any insight on Von Schlichten's comments here?

Remember Ashmodai! Remember Belphegor!

David
--
"And you know what English is? The result of the efforts of Norman men-at-arms to make dates with Saxon barmaids. . . ." - Victor Grego (H. Beam Piper), _Fuzzy_Sapiens_
~
^     All messages    << 297-312  257-296 of 2246  241-256 >>

Print | RSS Views: 35310 (Unique: 9358 ) / Subscribers: 27 | What's this?